Problem mit Sonoff Basic mit Tasmota: POWER State ändert sich OHNE physische Schaltung (3 von 30 Schalten haben dieses Problem).

Lucky

Hallo zusammen,

ich hoffe ihr könnt mir in dieser Angelegenheit helfen. Ich habe zu Hause ca. 30 Sonoffs verbaut, die meisten davon Touch, aber auch einige Basic und POW und TH10. Alle Schalter habe ich mit Tasmota geflasht, schon vor einiger Zeit - die aktuellste Version damals war: 5.13.0

Nachdem die Sonoffs stationär sind, ist natürlich der Wifi-Empfang nicht überall gut und es kommt bei ein paar Schaltern regelmäßig zu MQTT-reconnects. Sollte doch aber nicht so tragisch sein oder?

Nachdem einige Scripte nicht so funktionieren, wie geplant und sich die Schalter auch beim Schalten verselbstständigen, machbe ich angefangen die POWER-States zu überwachen.

Simple in einem Java-Script mit Zeilen wie diesen:

Code

on({id: "sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER"/*Licht_Aquarium POWER*/, change: "ne"}, function (obj) {
  var value = obj.state.val;
  var oldValue = obj.oldState.val;
  if (value != oldValue)
  {  
      if (getState("sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER").val === true) 
      {
          sendTo('telegram.0', 
          {
            text:                   'Licht Aquarium eingeschaltet',
            disable_notification:   false
          });
            console.log('Telegram: Licht Aquarium eingeschaltet');
      }else
      {
          sendTo('telegram.0', 
          {
            text:                   'Licht Aquarium ausgeschaltet',
            disable_notification:   false
          });
            console.log('Telegram: Licht Aquarium ausgeschaltet');
      }  
  }
});

Alles anzeigen

Jetzt ist folgendes auffällig:

- Manche Schalter feuern ein Status-Change-Event und der Schalter schaltet gar nicht

- Oft springt der Trigger on(...) 2 mal an, einmal mit einer Änderung auf false und gleich danach wieder auf true bzw. vice versa.

- Im ioBroker Log sehe ich die Status-Änderung gar nicht

Spoiler anzeigen

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:45.042 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:30.005 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.287 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Wifi_RSSI: {"val":38,"ack":true,"ts":1536221900270,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536220684977}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.286 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER: {"val":true,"ack":true,"ts":1536221900261,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900261}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.284 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Wifi_RSSI {"val":38,"ack":true,"ts":1536221900270,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536220684977}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.283 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER {"val":true,"ack":true,"ts":1536221900261,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900261}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.281 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Vcc: {"val":3.514,"ack":true,"ts":1536221900255,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900255}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.280 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Vcc {"val":3.514,"ack":true,"ts":1536221900255,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900255}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.258 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Uptime: {"val":"0T17:19:52","ack":true,"ts":1536221900251,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900251}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.258 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Uptime {"val":"0T17:19:52","ack":true,"ts":1536221900251,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900251}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.257 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Time: {"val":"2018-09-06T10:18:18","ack":true,"ts":1536221900246,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900246}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.256 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Time {"val":"2018-09-06T10:18:18","ack":true,"ts":1536221900246,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221900246}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:20.245 debug [Licht_Aquarium] Received: tele/Licht_Aquarium/STATE = {"Time":"2018-09-06T10:18:18","Uptime":"0T17:19:52","Vcc":3.514,"POWER":"ON","Wifi":{"AP":1,"SSId":"Smart.Alley","RSSI":38,"APMac":"78:11:DC:53:2

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:18:14.914 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:17:59.871 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:17:44.843 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:17:29.811 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:17:14.775 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:59.767 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:44.733 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:29.751 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER: {"val":false,"ack":true,"ts":1536221789743,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221613524}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:29.750 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER {"val":false,"ack":true,"ts":1536221789743,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221613524}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:29.744 debug [Licht_Aquarium] Received: cmnd/Licht_Aquarium/POWER =

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:29.696 debug stateChange sonoff.0.info.connection: {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küche,Mining_POW,Licht_

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:29.696 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.info.connection {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küc

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:29.690 info Client [Licht_Aquarium] reconnected. Old secret 1536221613465_3607. New secret 1536221789687_936

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:20.455 debug stateChange sonoff.0.info.connection: {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küche,Mining_POW,Licht_

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:20.455 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.info.connection {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küc

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:18.784 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:16:03.776 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:15:56.462 debug stateChange sonoff.0.info.connection: {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küche,Mining_POW,Licht_

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:15:56.461 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.info.connection {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küc

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:15:48.736 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:15:33.715 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:15:18.704 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:15:03.674 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:14:48.637 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:14:33.609 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:14:18.578 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:14:03.552 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:58.498 debug stateChange sonoff.0.info.connection: {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küche,Mining_POW,Licht_

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:58.497 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.info.connection {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küc

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:48.500 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:33.537 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER: {"val":false,"ack":true,"ts":1536221613524,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221613524}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:33.537 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER {"val":false,"ack":true,"ts":1536221613524,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221613524}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:33.525 debug [Licht_Aquarium] Received: cmnd/Licht_Aquarium/POWER =

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:33.477 debug stateChange sonoff.0.info.connection: {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küche,Mining_POW,Licht_

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:33.476 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.info.connection {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küc

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:33.471 info Client [Licht_Aquarium] reconnected. Old secret 1536221486064_1722. New secret 1536221613465_3607

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:26.304 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:20.461 debug stateChange sonoff.0.info.connection: {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küche,Mining_POW,Licht_

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:20.461 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.info.connection {"val":"Licht_Vorzimmer_Stiege,Licht_Kochfeld,Licht_Kellerstiege_Oben,Licht_Stiege_Kinderzimmer,Licht_Vorzimmer_Klo,Licht-Badezimmer,Licht_Küc

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.578 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Wifi_RSSI: {"val":38,"ack":true,"ts":1536221596570,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536220684977}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.578 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Wifi_RSSI {"val":38,"ack":true,"ts":1536221596570,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536220684977}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.577 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER: {"val":true,"ack":true,"ts":1536221596558,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596558}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.577 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.POWER {"val":true,"ack":true,"ts":1536221596558,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596558}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.563 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Vcc: {"val":3.517,"ack":true,"ts":1536221596555,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596555}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.562 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Vcc {"val":3.517,"ack":true,"ts":1536221596555,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596555}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.557 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Uptime: {"val":"0T17:14:48","ack":true,"ts":1536221596550,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596550}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.557 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Uptime {"val":"0T17:14:48","ack":true,"ts":1536221596550,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596550}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.552 debug stateChange sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Time: {"val":"2018-09-06T10:13:14","ack":true,"ts":1536221596546,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596546}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.552 debug redis pmessage io.sonoff.0.* io.sonoff.0.Licht_Aquarium.Time {"val":"2018-09-06T10:13:14","ack":true,"ts":1536221596546,"q":0,"from":"system.adapter.sonoff.0","lc":1536221596546}

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:16.545 debug [Licht_Aquarium] Received: tele/Licht_Aquarium/STATE = {"Time":"2018-09-06T10:13:14","Uptime":"0T17:14:48","Vcc":3.517,"POWER":"ON","Wifi":{"AP":1,"SSId":"Smart.Alley","RSSI":38,"APMac":"78:11:DC:53:2

sonoff.0 2018-09-06 10:13:11.215 debug Client [Licht_Aquarium] pingreq

- Im Log vom Sonoff steht auch nichts aufschlussreiches dazu:

Spoiler anzeigen

10:11:24 MQT: tele/Licht_Aquarium/LWT = Online (retained)

10:11:24 MQT: cmnd/Licht_Aquarium/POWER =

10:13:14 MQT: tele/Licht_Aquarium/STATE = {"Time":"2018-09-06T10:13:14","Uptime":"0T17:14:48","Vcc":3.517,"POWER":"ON","Wifi":{"AP":1,"SSId":"Smart.Alley","RSSI":38,"APMac":"78:11:DC:53:28:4B"}}

10:13:31 DNS: Initialized

10:13:31 MQT: Attempting connection...

10:13:31 MQT: Connected

10:13:31 MQT: tele/Licht_Aquarium/LWT = Online (retained)

10:13:31 MQT: cmnd/Licht_Aquarium/POWER =

10:16:27 DNS: Initialized

10:16:28 MQT: Attempting connection...

10:16:28 MQT: Connected

10:16:28 MQT: tele/Licht_Aquarium/LWT = Online (retained)

10:16:28 MQT: cmnd/Licht_Aquarium/POWER =

10:18:18 MQT: tele/Licht_Aquarium/STATE = {"Time":"2018-09-06T10:18:18","Uptime":"0T17:19:52","Vcc":3.514,"POWER":"ON","Wifi":{"AP":1,"SSId":"Smart.Alley","RSSI":38,"APMac":"78:11:DC:53:28:4B"}}

- Wenn ich den Schalter über Tasmota schalte, dann sieht das log OK aus: [Licht_Aquarium] Received: stat/Licht_Aquarium/POWER = OFF

Einen Schalter trifft es besonders oft. Hier ein Auszug aus der Information von Tasmota:

Spoiler anzeigen

Program Version 5.13.0

Build Date & Time 2018-04-29T21:44:16

Core/SDK Version 2_4_1/2.2.1(cfd48f3)

Uptime 0T17:25:24

Flash write Count 12286 at F5000

Boot Count 6641

Restart Reason Hardware Watchdog

Friendly Name 1 Sonoff

AP1 SSId (RSSI) Smart.Alley (38%)

Hostname Licht-Aquarium

IP Address 10.0.0.182

Gateway 10.0.0.100

Subnet Mask 255.255.255.0

DNS Server 10.0.0.100

MAC Address 60:01:94:73:B3:EF

MQTT Host 10.0.0.181

MQTT Port 1883

MQTT Client &

Fallback Topic Licht_Aquarium

MQTT User Sonoff

MQTT Topic Licht_Aquarium

MQTT Group Topic sonoffs

MQTT Full Topic cmnd/Licht_Aquarium/

Emulation None

mDNS Discovery Enabled

mDNS Advertise Web Server

ESP Chip Id 7582703

Flash Chip Id 1327198

Flash Size 1024kB

Program Flash Size 1024kB

Program Size 534kB

Free Program Space 468kB

Free Memory 20kB

Ich habe noch folgende Configs gesetzt:

Spoiler anzeigen

10:30:08 CMD: sleep

10:30:08 MQT: stat/Licht_Aquarium/RESULT = {"Sleep":"50 (50)"}

10:30:10 CMD: wificonfig

10:30:10 MQT: stat/Licht_Aquarium/RESULT = {"WifiConfig":"5 (Wait)"}

Liegt das Problem an den Reconnects?

Habt ihr einen Tipp, was ich an meiner Konfiguration ändern könnte?

LG,

Lucky

Jetzt mitmachen!